We are going to cut taxes for 95 percent of Americans,” Barack Obama‘s campaign manager, David Plouffe, said in the spin room here at Hofstra University following the final debate of the 2008 presidential election.

Plouffe was repeating one of the boldest claims made by the Obama campaign. It’s a claim that the Wall Street Journal editorial board dubbed “Obama’s 95% Illusion,” noting that more than a third of Americans don’t pay any income taxes, and that what Obama’s plan does do is offer a raft of subsidies and government payments to individuals and families that he redefines as “tax cuts.”

So when Plouffe reiterated the 95 percent claim, Philip Klein writing for The American Spectator asked him a simple question aimed at clarifying whether Obama’s tax plan was about cutting rates, or merely handing out government checks.

Read the full story here.