I was pleased I watched yesterday’s National Press Club address by John Hartigan on the telly, rather than live. Yes, I missed out on the opportunity to ask a question of him, like inquiring as to how many staff he had sacked in recent months, or congratulating him on keeping a straight face when he used the words “News Ltd” and “integrity” in the same sentence. I was initially impressed he was speaking without notes, but wondered why he’d say a few sentences looking left, and then look right, pause or stumble on his words, and resume.
Only one brief cutaway shot eventually revealed what had been kept out of sight — he was using one of those Obama-style dual teleprompters, but kept losing his place whenever he looked at the other screen. Naughty ABC OB producer for showing up the News Ltd CEO like that. It was probably revenge for the fact that Hartigan used a solid 10 minutes of advertising-free ABC airtime to promote News Ltd products.
Oh, and what great coverage News Ltd provided of the Victorian bushfires. And to what exceptional profit! That was a particularly tasteful moment.
Things move slowly in the mainstream media, however. Hartigan went to great lengths to endorse the views of Andrew Keen, whose attack on the evils of blogging and “citizen journalism”, The Great Seduction, came out in 2007. Keen, who is these days a, um, blogger, has suggested the internet is worse than Nazism, although Keen’s real objection to the internet is the communist threat it poses to intellectual property rights — which is where he and News Ltd share an agenda.
News Ltd’s real beef is not with the despised bloggers or the likes of Crikey whom he singled out, but with content aggregators and the mighty Google whom he suggests are hijacking large amounts of online advertising revenue that should be flowing to Rupert.
The simple solution, as Hartigan noted, is to start charging for content, and move all that great stuff away from the clutches of Google to somewhere safely behind a paywall.
Hartigan is absolutely right. The more News Ltd content that is moved beyond a paywall the better. Here are six pieces of News Ltd material that we’d love to see out of reach of non-subscribers.
Soft-core porn on News Ltd tabloid websites. Never mind the regular moral panics run by News Ltd, you and your kids can see plenty of flesh — almost invariably female flesh — just a few clicks into News Ltd’s galleries. See why see Heidi Klum’s a Victoria Secret glamourpus! Former Hi-5 member Kellie Crawford has shed her children’s image for something more adult! Pregnant celebrities pose! Plenty of websites make good money from this stuff.
Virulent ethnocentrism from commentators.
What did Hartigan say about bloggers yesterday? “Something of such limited intellectual value as to be barely discernible from massive ignorance.” There’s probably no commercial case here — your average dribbling redneck isn’t going to shell out their hard-earned when there’s so much hate out there for free, but at least it’ll keep this sort of stuff from infecting legitimate debate.
Opinion poll spinning
There was only one thing funnier than watching John Howard struggle to avoid his electoral doom in 2007, and that was watching Dennis Shanahan try every possible reading of the polls to explain how a Howard victory was inevitable. This Comical Ali act was champagne comedy and many of us would pay good money to have a repeat in the run up to next year’s election.
News Ltd’s coverage of Rupert Murdoch’s business affairs
A cost-free option because, apart from extravagant praise of the Dear Leader’s genius, there ain’t any.
Angela Shanahan and Christopher Pearson
We’re talking about targeting audiences here. Who needs an insight in pre-Reformation Catholicism? Who are the sort of people interested in exploring religious views unleavened even by the Twelfth Century Renaissance? Yep, academic historians. And they’ll pay good money for this sort of documentary evidence of medieval thinking. Charging for Angela Shanahan and Christopher Pearson is, aptly, a no-brainer.
Hartigan also said he wanted to close News Ltd’s Press Gallery office (although this was edited out of the version now appearing on The Oz site) and reduce coverage of politics in favour of “hyper-localism” such as petrol prices and shopping information. So much for quality journalism. News Ltd political journalists, even the most biased ones, understand that in-depth political coverage and analysis is important. The boss clearly doesn’t.
Crikey is committed to hosting lively discussions. Help us keep the conversation useful, interesting and welcoming. We aim to publish comments quickly in the interest of promoting robust conversation, but we’re a small team and we deploy filters to protect against legal risk. Occasionally your comment may be held up while we review, but we’re working as fast as we can to keep the conversation rolling.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please subscribe to leave a comment.
The Crikey comment section is members-only content. Please login to leave a comment.