data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dc2b8/dc2b8798e82c67dc4b6da3b4144d2b783e659301" alt=""
One of the clear differences between Scott Morrison and Malcolm Turnbull that became evident after the former replaced the latter was that Morrison and his office were far less likely to sit back and do nothing while problems worsened. Instead, they would move quickly on political sore points and deal with them — sometimes inelegantly, but the results were better than the inclination of Turnbull’s political machine to let things drift and fester.
Now, however, the Morrison government is marked by a strange passivity. After its fiscal flurry last year and its closure of Australia’s borders, its management of the pandemic has been complacent and slow: no new quarantine facilities have been built, Australians overseas and desperate to return home have been abandoned, its hastily-developed tracing app is an expensive and now-ignored joke, and the vaccine rollout has been a debacle despite months of additional planning and preparation compared to overseas.
Now that debacle threatens to have a real human cost if the Victorian outbreak spreads — as has been reported this morning — into aged care facilities which should have had vaccinations completed by the end of March. If the government had even vaguely reached its revised target — even missed it by just a month — then this potential tragedy would have been averted.
The passivity seems to have extended to the ability of Morrison’s staff to manage ongoing political problems. With hindsight, it’s unlikely that the Morrison brains trust would have used the phrase “it’s not a race” about the rollout — a phrase first used by the Coalition’s hand-picked health secretary Brendan Murphy on March 10 and by Morrison himself, twice, in interviews the following day, in what was clearly a deliberately chosen talking point. “It’s not a race. It’s not a competition,” Morrison would say repeatedly.
The thinking behind such a phrase was to make sure that Australians understood the vaccine was safe and proper safeguards were in place, for fear of giving anti-vaxxers any room to encourage hesitancy. The blood clots caused by the AstraZeneca vaccine put paid to that, no matter how trivially rare they are.
But now the government is unable to find a way to quietly dump the phrase. Instead, ministers have to parrot it or they contradict the prime minister. Deputy PM Michael McCormack parroted it yesterday, in the face of clear evidence from Victoria that it is very much a race, very much a competition, not with other countries — although the government has stopped invoking international comparisons as our slow rollout has taken us further and further behind — but with the next outbreak.
And there will always be a next outbreak because we know hotel quarantine — the system the government has complacently relied on — will always produce them.
Not that the government has always been consistent with the “it’s not a race” rhetoric. Remember the “war footing” that the Prime Minister’s Office duped gullible journalists into repeating back in mid-April when it became painfully obvious the rollout was a disaster? For about a week, it wasn’t a race, but it was a war. But then the bi-weekly national cabinet meetings were abandoned, and “no one mention the war” became the new mantra.
Behind it all is Morrison’s strange reluctance, or inability, to lead: on vaccination, on repatriation, on quarantine, on borders (where Morrison has embraced the fortress mentality of state premiers with the zeal of a convert), not to mention non-pandemic issues like climate, Indigenous recognition and integrity. Even on aged care, where he has promised “generational reform”, Morrison has only been forced into action by the aged care royal commission and the deaths of hundreds of seniors in nursing homes last year.
No wonder he embraced “not a race” as a mantra. For Morrison, there’s never any risk of him being out in front.
If there was anything that should have been accomplished on time it is vaccination of aged care and disabled residents plus the staff and their families. It was such an opportunity for the govt to show they can do something right and take all the credit. I am astounded they did not do whatever it would take to make sure it was done no matter what the cost – what were they thinking? Then again maybe I should not be astounded.
Or maybe they didn’t have the supplies of vaccine – which they were never going to admit.
How much Pfizer has been thrown out because the delivery was so badly organized? The answer is not known either because it is a cabinet secret, or the records were not kept – who knows?
But there was time and ability to vaccinate military personnel going to the USA, and athletes going to a Covid weary Japan. Success?
It is very clear that the federal government would like to turn over their aged care beds.
What better way to do that than letting Covid19 run rampant as it did last year.
Last year the federally funded and supervised private aged care facilities had all of the deaths, which they tried to blame on Dan Andrews government and mostly got away with.
It drops the costs of aged care for a while and reduces the the waiting list, doesn’t it?
Would this be a good reason why the 1A’s in these aged care facilities and the disability care facilities and their carers have not been fully vaccinated?
Not incompetence but malfeasance?
$$$$$$$$$$$ talk!
Sadly, I agree with you. Morrison WANTS covid 19 to rip through Australia. If he didnt want this, he would have prioritised purpose built quarantine facilities & the vaccine roll out. Morrison flirted with QANON & is clearly a member of a death cult posing as a religion. We are not allowed to mention this on the Guardian website for fear of Morison’s wrath. He is a vengeful man. An incompetent, delusional Trump loving lump of uselessness.
Logistics and meaningful activity aren’t in Morrison’s DNA, he is a small-government do-nothing in a position of power purely for its own sake, a man who thinks federal governance is about privatisation, handling money, consolidating his personal power base, while being as inactive as possible on issues affecting the people.
The idea that there are national services too vital to be left up to private industry and the profit motive, bounce off his other-worldly carapace…even as a tsunami bears down on him and the country, all he can do is stand there like a stunned rabbit and focus on a) how this is nothing to do with him, and b) that he should figure out who to blame.
He literally cannot lead, he lacks the most fundamental quality of a leader, ie, the ability to envisage a future, a way forward, and then make it occur.
Instead he exists in this eternal now, quite unmoved by events until they hurt him in the polls, and only then can he be stirred into action – by doing just enough to make the issue retreat for the moment.
Instead of helping Victoria with its outbreak, he will be putting all his energies in constructing a narrative where the fault is 100% the state government’s, because he’s not interested in helping the australian people, it’s all about him.
Well said.
Also, as you imply, he lacks problem solving and analytical thinking skills. I’ve worked long enough to know these are rarely found in a leader these days, but really, can you call yourself a leader without them?
He’s more of a front man i guess.
Abbott was a total front man. If he hadn’t been such an utter utter idiot, he’d probably still be PM but he was too much of a jacked up twit for even the far right of the party. Abbott reminded me of Rudolf Hess, fanatical but so unbelievably stupid he thought he could parachute into England, have a face to face with Churchill, and then be let go.
Morrison is more bendy, harder to nail down, he’s that liquid Terminator from the second film as opposed to Abbott’s clunky but brutal T-800.
But without wanting to sound all conspiracy theorist, who are the higher powers in the party who the leader has to appease? It’s clearly a group on the far right who are the ones to be feared, but who are they? I assume it’s a group, and i assume the strength of their hold over Morrison waxes and wanes according to his successes and failures of the time. I’d love to know their names.
With a majority of 1 in Parliament a group wanting to intimidate the Government doesn’t need to be very big. But I think commentators discussing a hard-right group dominating the Government overlook Morrison’s own leanings, basically very comfortable with that group.
I’d love to know their names too. But maybe there is no one twisting Morrison’s arm up his back.
He may just have a personality flaw whereby he needs to be loved and acknowledged and so hands out more favours than are needed.
One prime motivation for Morrison is working out how to Christianise the nation. He is trapped in an evangelical mindset about how he can ‘save’ the nation and prepare it for the imminent second coming of Christ.
Everything else is therefore secondary, hence the lies, avoidance of critical social issues and even the hands off, blame shifting approach to COVID.
What’s more to understand in this evangelical mindset is that he actively avoids meeting, engaging and dealing with difficult issues (eg avoid going to women’s march) because he thinks the devil is present and he doesn’t want to be seen by his evangelical peers to be getting too close to old mate Satan.
You can be sure that his prayer breakfast buddies will be seeking the Lord’s direction on these matters, not how to improve the well being of the needy.
I tried to raise this issue on the Guardian website but all my comments were removed by the moderator. There is something VERY WRONG with democracy in Australia when NO ONE in the MSM will tackle this issue. Clearly the PM believes in the coming ‘end days’ & will not prioritise covid 19 measures because he believes covid is all part of his sociopathic god’s plan.
He certainly reminds me of those Mr Bendy figures one sees at used car yards – especially at that photo-op around the last election at his “church” waving his arms and babbling tongues.
I’m sure you know the quote, “There go the people, I must follow them for I am their leader.”
“he is a small-government do-nothing”
… except where it comes to handing out money, contract, jobs, sinecures and awards to favoured friends
A dog in a manger can’t lead.
When will Crikey or other media dig into the stand-out question in the Aged Care vaccination numbers. By the Commonwealth’s own rollout numbers way more aged care vaccinations were occurring in Queensland in March and April than Victoria. https://www.health.gov.au/resources/collections/covid-19-vaccine-rollout-updates. See the daily update numbers for 30 April for example – NSW 72,000, Queensland 56,000, Victoria 44,000. More aged care residents in Queensland than Victoria per capita? Maybe. More marginal seats? Absolutely. With winter approaching who the hell would think it logical to roll out slower in Victoria than Queensland.
Vaccination numbers? Does that mean how many vaccinations completed Brian? One would think so. But then there is the question. How many vaccine jabs were provided? In order that an individual could have the jab. Is it not Brian the responsibility of Federal Govt to purchase, supply to States and Territories in order that people can be vaccinated? I have an understanding of one Territory and one State roll-out and both had, have, difficulty in accessing vaccine? Specifically, aged/disabled persons who were crying out to be vaccinated? Since March? This is not a game. Nor is the virus static!
I think Brian is indeed pointing the finger at the Fed Govt.
As Deipnosoph says below, I am indeed pointing the finger at the Commonwealth Government, not the states. And I have nothing against the good people in Queensland aged care – everyone deserves to be vaccinated as quickly as possible. But the figures show that jabs have slowed to a trickle in Qld aged care in the last few weeks – suggesting most facilities have been completed for their first shot – but jabs have ramped up in Victoria. The problem is that it takes several weeks for post-vaccine immunity to develop, winter conditions are well and truly here in Melbourne, and COVID has now entered aged care facilities. So my question is – was the Commonwealth’s uneven rollout across the states a medical strategy, a cock-up or a political conspiracy, given the well-recognised distribution of marginal seats across the country? If you think the latter is far fetched I suggest you give the Auditor-General a call and ask to speak to the staff that audited sports rorts and the regional grants program.
They’re all good questions that go to root cause. I’m not sure that journalism has caught up with that yet.
Colour coded vaccine roll out. As to be expected…..maaaates…..
“It’s not a race. It’s not a competition, …”
It appears the virus hasn’t heard the news.
Morrison is not a leader. That we know for sure.
the new mantra should be “A liar, not a leader”
Pity that no party will use that on an election poster.
I am sure the recent Crilkey series will be giving the opposition parties a few free kicks, lets see what they do with them.
Depends what one means by “opposition parties” – in the case of the empty husk that once was Labor, SFA would be the answer.
Too afraid of being wedged, traduced or bullied by NewsCorpse.
In the Queensland state election they came very close to that whilst describing Clive Palmer and his death taxes.
I’m not sure why Morrison would feel the need to lead. Abbott didn’t, neither did Turnbull. Shorten did, with terrific policies galore. And who did the Aussie voters reward? The talkers, not the doers.
Morrison is more than just a talker. By under-rating his appeal you also under-rate the difficulty of unseating him.
Morrison has more charisma than Shorten or Albanese. He is on the move – always on the go with a phalanx of experts, spin-doctors, bureaucrats and experts in tow to create and maintain the aura of a team. He is well-dressed, well-groomed and is never short of words. He mixes effortlesslesly (c.f. Biden’s fear of mixing).
Great mixing after the bushfire, well-dressed in a baseball cap, never answers a question…
Assaulting a pregnant woman who did not want to shake his hand, being told to P__S OFF by a fire water tanker driver.
Classicly good look, turning up on the fireground in a fleet of white BMW X5’s trying to get some grateful native shots, yes he certainly looked like a winner didn’t he??
Babbling creme-faced loons have appeal ?
Poor country Australia <groan>.
Yeah a well rehearsed shitshow and…..
Still a show I don’t want to see
I think you might be wrong. He cannot handled being challenged on the ground ie Bush fire suffering people. I do not understand how you you can weave Biden into Morrison. He belongs to a church of con artists who suck money out of the congregation. Tithe 10% to the church.
I hope I am wrong. I am trying to understand his appeal, not to back him.
Almost everyone else writing here assumes that their assessment of Morrison is so widely shared he’ll be obliterated at the next poll. I don’t think so. I am playing devil’s advocate here so that the next election isn’t another “unlosable” election for Labor, just as the 2019 election was.
Not sure about the charisma. He spends all his energy on personal PR and doesn’t have time (or the know-how or interest) in policy.
Of all the adjectives used to describe Scummo, “charisma” is not one I have ever heard.
I gave your comment a + as well, but there are, at the moment, enough Australians who will willingly vote for him rather than the opposition should an election be held in the next few months.
is an opportunistic
Mention his beliefs & the role they play in his decision making & you will be censored. I wonder why?
Morrison is an Ass -no doubt but this article says: “for fear of giving anti-vaxxers any room to encourage hesitancy. The blood clots caused by the AstraZeneca vaccine put paid to that, no matter how trivially rare they are.”
Trival they are NOT ! The true real & ongoing problems from the various Vaccines are being hidden & not at all well reported. There is a lot at stake here both for Government who have committed to expensive purchases & to the Pharama Companies themselves. Think they’re going to publish all teh problem ? If so you’re a bunny ! Facts are
Pfizer alone: 3,760 deaths and 134,606 injuries to 10/04/2021. Check this shortened link :https://tinyurl.com/y4cztnsp
There are scores of reports – amongst others check out short video 4th story down. @ Canadian Doctor Breaks Gag Order: Speaks Publicly On Moderna Covid-19 Vaccine Harm in First Nations Community:
Antivaxxer: -Anyone who declines or criticises any of the Covid-19 vaccines, regardless of their reasons and general attitude towards vaccination – even if they are a well-regarded medical scientist who has been involved in the development of vaccines for many years. Any evidence produced by the antivaxxer is irrelevant because proof denies faith and without faith ‘The Science’ is nothing.
Infection fatality rate (IFR): Probably the most important metric in assessing the lethality of a pathogen, IFR is the percentage of infected people who die. For SARS-CoV-2 the current estimate is between 0.24% and 0.15% – for comparison bad flu is between 0.1 and 0.2% and rabies is 100%. Due to its vital importance, IFR is never mentioned by the mainstream media and most people have no idea what it means.
Mate, around 50 blood clot related incidences present to hospitals in this country every day. Vaccine related blood clots make just a tiny blob in those stats.
blib, not blob. Thanks Crikey bot…
Blip!!!
So get your jab – very brave of you. Just don’t virtue signal that you’ve had it. Good luck in the lottery.
Just don’t virtue signal that you’ve had it.
So last year.
Antivaxer. I looked at your link typical bunch of unscientific anecdotal nonsense. Randomised trials involving 10s of thousands of cases compare side effects in cases who receive placebo with cases randomly selected given vaccine. Neither case knows which one. Serious side effects from vaccine about 1 per 100,000. Watch out for bill gates microchips coming to get you.
“Watch out for bill gates microchips coming to get you.”
Sounds like it is too late Brett, but it may be the Trump, not the Gates chip.
Watch out for bill gates microchips coming to get you.
It’s you who will have to be careful -I’m already watching.
I’m glad you looked at the link – Your comment also said – unscientific anecdotal nonsense?
Please publish your rebuttal with some verified data to back up your response .
It’s your comment that’s nonsense but it will be different IF you’re the one that gets an adverse affect.
“Mortality rate 0.24-0.15%. Rubbish in the USA already around 500,000 deaths. That’s 0.2% and only 10-20% of the population infected. That would place mortality rate around 1% which is the actual rate reported. This rate goes up rapidly over the age of 60 to well over 5%.
Sorry omitted to close quotation marks after 0.12-0.2%
Lots of babbling from unreliable sources does not increase your credibility.
The part of the infection with Covid19 which get very little air time is that, no matter how healthy you are, the figures which are most important, the Long Covid syndrome which works out as 1 in 3 who get the infection also get the syndrome.
Blown heart valves needing surgery, strokes causing brain damage, kidney damage with some needing dialysis, scarred lungs leading to right sided heart failure, eye damage, clotting of the gut vessels leading to some big trouble, thyroiditis and chronic fatigue all due to Covid19 being an infliction of the lining of blood vessels are just some of the damage done to otherwise healthy people aged between 18 and 40.
And so, this rubbish about the vaccination roll out not being a race demonstrates that this government could not even hire a bunch of consultants to run a chook raffle, let alone a vaccination roll out.
My oh my you have been frightened beyond belief by the rabid MSM reporting 24/7. If you’re an older adult
(say over 40) you should know that most info you get from MSM is only partially true if that. One lie we were told was that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction – that’s one of many in a long list ! Spectator Australia https://tinyurl.com/4aepvuyb lays it out. If you have time ( and don’t mind facts) -take a look.
Checked out the web site suggested. Rose has a lot to say. No indication of quals. and background. Looka very much like an anti vaxer site.
Strangely Jimmy turns up every time there is an article about how appallingly badly the Morrison government has bollocksed its shambles of a vaccine roll out. His aim seems to be to deflect people away from focusing on the government’s many failings and into pointless arguing about baseless claims against the efficacy of vaccination per se and the idiotic claims of the anti vax brigade. I suggest it is best to ignore him.
If not fed perhaps he’ll go back under the bridge and only anny billy goats?
…or “annoy billy goats”.
He and his ministers don’t do public administration. They only message and organise vote-buying and payoffs