Can-do capitalism, we barely knew ye.
Last week, addressing the Victorian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Scott Morrison unveiled his new mantra, repeating “can-do capitalism” in his speech and the following Q&A. “Can-do capitalism” would fix climate change, but it was “a good motto for us to follow not just in this area, but right across the spectrum of economic policy in this country”.
So good a motto that Morrison has not uttered it once since that day.
Some bright young spark in the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) came up with the line as a great summation of Scott Morrison’s election campaign theme that he was for freedom and Labor was for compulsion. But because political staffers, like many of the journalists they spoon-feed, don’t have memories longer than five minutes, it sailed all the way through into the prime minister’s speech and splashed across the Liberals’ News Corp newsletters without anyone recalling the fate of Can-Do Campbell Newman in Queensland.
Labor happily didn’t let the phrase pass unremarked up north.
The penny evidently dropped in the PMO later that day, and the phrase was immediately terminated with extreme prejudice. Perhaps like the staffer who proposed it.
A similar treatment awaited the government’s electric vehicle policy, the announcement of which went down so well the PMO didn’t bother posting the transcript of the ensuing press conference, which was dominated by the issue of Morrison’s lies. Any mention of electric vehicles by Morrison now simply reminds everyone that he’s a compulsive liar. By the end of last week, electric vehicles had been dropped and he was lashing out at Anthony Albanese for “backing in China” to the visible confusion of interviewers.
This week saw a different tack on economic policy, with Morrison returning to the John Howard idea of labelling Labor the party of higher interest rates and higher petrol prices, without any explanation of exactly how Labor would push interest rates higher given that the gravamen of Howard’s charge was that Labor’s spending would be undisciplined and thus force the Reserve Bank to increase rates. As it turned out that neatly summarised the last term of Howard himself.
It’s a hard charge to maintain when Morrison has a $100 billion deficit and plans to run the biggest government since World War II well into the 2020s.
Josh Frydenberg overnight used the government’s prime stenographer to signal he was committing to a Menziean era of full employment. That will drive up wages growth, of course, and therefore create the inflation conditions for the Reserve Bank to… raise interest rates. Confusingly, Morrison is thus warning that Labor will cause exactly what his own treasurer says is the government’s policy.
One can only hope Frydenberg doesn’t inflict the 5.5% interest rates that were normal under Menzies on us now, given the implications for heavily indebted households. Or did Frydenberg’s office not check what interest rates were in the 1950s before exhuming the sainted Sir Robert?
The chances of full employment are virtually zero given the government’s determination to return to pre-pandemic migration patterns — hundreds of thousands of temporary workers forcing wages down across a variety of industries, with Coalition donors spared the problem of either paying higher wages to Australians or going without staff (and endlessly whining to the Financial Review about it).
Migration is a sleeper issue for the election, and Morrison faces a pincer movement on it, from the far right from Pauline Hanson and from Labor on temporary migration and wages growth. This week’s Wage Price Index numbers, showing households enduring further real wage cuts, illustrate the risk to household incomes from rapidly expanding the labour supply.
Labor, meanwhile, continues to keep a low profile, to the chagrin of supporters. It did roll out one high-profile policy this week, however, on completely safe ground: the NBN.
Until the submarine debacle came along, the NBN was the government’s most expensive policy failure — spending significantly more than Labor’s original fibre plan to deliver a sub-standard soup of different technologies so poor that people on the east coast are turning to Elon Musk’s colossal act of sky vandalism, Starlink, for better service. Worse still, on NBN the government has one of its worst performers, the lethargic Paul Fletcher, “prosecuting” its case that it hasn’t been what the electorate is convinced it is — a colossal stuff-up.
Morrison can only hope botching the NBN has been priced into his vote by the electorate already.
What’s next week’s line for Morrison? He fired the gun on this early election campaign last week and he’s already chewed through multiple attack lines that have mainly served to remind people of negative characteristics of the Coalition or himself, and confused us as to exactly what the government’s economic policy is.
The press gallery are reluctant to say it because they wrote Morrison off before the 2019 election, only to be surprised by his “miracle” win — but if he’s the political genius they believe him to be, the evidence is a long time coming at the moment.
Still, a long way ’til polling day. A long, long, long way.
I seriously think Sco Mo is losing it, he bumbles and blusters then back tracks to find out where he got confused.
i think he engages his mouth before his brain kicks in!
He has lost it no maybe . Thrashing the truth and embarrassing mainstream religion. One lie after another.
The sad fact is he is not afraid of lying, as that is what has got him where he is now
Mr. Morrison’s brain is not involved in his speaking. His words and syntax come from on high, sometimes in a kind of English, sometimes in unknown tongues.
Is that the secret of it. He’s engaging in high level, highly honest glossolalia and we’re ignorantly hearing something different.
Does his mouth kick in before his brain? I don’t think, I know.
Brain ?
Yes brain it sends a wobbly signal to his mouth
His mouth is perfectly trained to emit the signal no check on content just get it out always chance to re send another signal later
Receiving that signal ?….
If there’s no content, it’s noise, not signal.
Although he is basically on the nose in Queensland the UAP with Craig Kelly fronting it is certain to pull above his last effort of 3% of the national vote. Their preferences will ultimately end up with the Coalition.
It was Clive who pushed three seats to Scomo last time, enough to get him over the line proving it possible to buy an election and keep his cash coming in.
So far Scomo is making a hash of his election campaign. Labor are wise to wait while he continues to make mistakes and tell more lies..
Don N
Yes as per Napoleon, “Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake”. Or when his BS is growing obvious and wearing thin.
At some point you do need to enter the field but for now he is being denied his strengths, negativity, outrage and attacking other’s ideas. He doesn’t do policy, he does announcements and there have been so many that amount to nothing that approach is losing effectiveness. A Crikey list of announcements and what became of them would be a good thing.
Sco Mo has lost W A, Palmer would be tarred and feathered if he set foot in that State.
I guess it comes down to how much Scummo can take as he seems to be unravelling and people need keep up the barrage.
Everyone has a breaking point and no amount of god bothering will help him. Personally I say good riddance as he is nothing more than a snake oil salesman
Just hope he takes Barnaby with him as neither could form a microscopic brain cell btwn them
Our beloved PM makes snake-oil salesmen appear trustworthy, by comparison.
Dear Clive must start running out of funds soon – for example, he’s been a Titanic failure in forcing his way into WA.
“He fired the gun on this early election campaign last week and he’s already chewed through multiple attack lines that have mainly served to remind people of negative characteristics of the Coalition or himself, and confused us as to exactly what the government’s economic policy is.”
Given that Scotty from Marketing was sacked from two marketing CEO jobs, why is there surprise that he cannot market his Government and its achievements……
Exactly, people have had enough of do nothing governments. The contrast with Andrews, I say what I’ll do and then I do what I say, could not be starker.
First of all, he needs some achievements to list.
Not fair! Here’s some achievements that Morrison can list:
Hmm. All right, I’m beginning to see the problem
Extending the ‘achievements’ back to 2013: The destruction of the car industry in Australia, abandoning the price on Carbon which was actually achieving is stated aims. And of course, the whole NBN stuff up.
Reflects items in the ‘Can do capitalism’ list which are also the same in the Anglosphere i.e. UK, US etc.; channeling but masking key Kochian ‘radical right libertarian’ socioeconomic policies, presented benignly as ‘public choice theory’ or ‘freedom & liberty’ (of Chicago School ideologue James Buchanan, who stayed in the background, but made his peers and public figures like Friedman, Rand et al. appear soft).
Further, seems to require crazy behaviour from ‘leaders’, MPs or Reps and media cooperation, in citing threats to attract/deflect attention whether imagined, domestic, international or existential.
Dutton is the ‘leader’ on the last one – don’t give The PM all the debit.
Stopping Dutton being PM is about it.
Not quite correct. He fled the New Zealand job before the letter could be issued.
I thought when visited there for the first time Adern may have had the police arrest him on charges of theft.
Joe Hockey once claimed an RBA cash rate of 2.5%(?) was an emergency level and a sign of a poorly performing economy. Now Morrison wants us to believe low interest rates are a sign of good economic management. So which one is it and who is the liar? Could it be both of them?
Do nothing Government.
Seat warming sinecure.
Liars r Us
Lying for Righteousness
Policy for sale